Zero-Click Search "2.0": How AI Searches Are Changing Organic Search Traffic & What Brands Should Do About It

Alexander Soliman
Dec 6, 2025
4 min read

Search hasn’t stopped growing — but clicks to websites have.

That’s the uncomfortable paradox behind “Zero-Click Search 2.0,” the new era where AI assistants and AI-enhanced SERPs answer user questions before a click ever happens.

Rand Fishkin’s 2024 zero-click research with SparkToro and Datos found that only 360–374 out of every 1,000 Google searches in the US/EU result in a click to the open web, with ~58–60% ending in zero clicks.

*Google results statistics and Zero clicks for Americans & Europeans searches by Sparktoro*

Now, with AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Gemini AI Mode, and Perplexity, we’re entering a second phase where even more searches are resolved without users visiting independent sites.

From “Zero-Click Search” to “Zero-Click 2.0”

When Rand Fishkin coined and popularized the modern “zero-click search” framing, the problem was already big: most Google searches ended with no click at all.

In 2024, 58.5% of US and 59.7% of EU Google searches ended without any click to a website. Roughly 36–37% of searches produced a click to the open web; the rest went to Google’s own properties or nowhere.

In 2024–2025, Rand also showed that Google search volume grew 20%+ YoY and still receives ~373× more searches than ChatGPT, reinforcing that Google remains the dominant front door to information — even as AI tools grow.

“Zero-Click Search 2.0” is what happens when you add AI layers on top of that:

Google’s AI Overviews / AI Mode answer many queries in-line.
AI assistants like ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity act as primary search tools for some users, synthesizing answers from multiple sources and citing only a few.
Consumers increasingly expect full answers from AI without needing to click anything at all.

The result: traditional organic clicks shrink even further, even though total search + AI-query volume keeps rising.

How AI Searches Are Accelerating Zero-Click Behavior

AI Overviews on Google Search

AI Overviews sit above organic results, and for many informational queries, they:

Aggregate information from multiple sites
Summarize it into a single, conversational answer
Show only a handful of citations

So the user journey becomes: query → AI answer → new query (or “I’m done”), rather than query → click → explore site.

*AI Overviews appear on top of the search results aggregating information from multiple sources*

ChatGPT, Perplexity & Gemini as Discovery Engines

AI assistants now behave like parallel search ecosystems:

Gen-AI platforms are reshaping customer journeys, with AI discovery and citation patterns creating new visibility challenges.
Zero-click searches on Google climbed, ChatGPT referrals to websites increased 25× YoY, but from a very small base — not nearly enough to offset lost Google traffic for most publishers.
Rand Fishkin shared commentary on new research showing that 65% of consumers now expect to get their “ideal answer” directly from AI overviews, and ~20% expect AI alone — not blue links — to solve their query. He frames Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) as the new baseline for discoverability.

*AI Mode can now be seen as a standalone search ecosystem*

The Organic Traffic Impact: The Great Decoupling

Several 2025 analyses have described a “Great Decoupling” as: search usage grows, but referrals to websites fall.

For many industries generally and news publishers specifically, Similarweb data (covered in major media) shows that after AI Overviews launched, zero-click news searches jumped from 56% to 69%, while monthly organic visits to top news sites fell from ~2.3B to under 1.7B

*Impressions & clicks decoupling impact since the launch of AI Overviews globally*

What Brands Should Stop Expecting

Before we talk about solutions, let's reset the traditional expectations from organic search strategies:

From Old Mental Model (Pre-AI)

“If we rank on page one, we’ll see traffic.”
“If we own the featured snippet, we’ll get a strong CTR.”
“SEO success = organic sessions & last-click conversions.”

To a New Mental Model (Zero-Click 2.0)

You can appear in AI Overviews or AI assistants without seeing a proportional traffic bump.
Rankings and impressions may rise while sessions stay flat or drop (“great decoupling”).
Brand exposure inside AI answers can drive indirect value (search uplift, branded navigation, offline conversions) that won’t always show in last-click reports.

If you only judge SEO by organic sessions, Zero-Click 2.0 will look like failure — even when your brand is still highly visible in the new ecosystem.

Adapting to Zero Clicks 2.0

Strategy Shift #1: Measure AI Visibility, Not Just Clicks

Start by adding AI traffic and citations as separate layers in your measurement, comparing yourself to your competitors and industry averages:

Tag and monitor referrals from chat.openai.com, perplexity.ai, and other Gen-AI domains in GA4/analytics.
Use tools or frameworks to perform AI citation gap analysis to see which AI answers cite your site vs competitors.
Run periodic manual tests in ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity for your key topics and note:
- Are you cited?
- How often vs competitors?
- Which assets (guides, product pages, studies) are being referenced?

Strategy Shift #2: Embrace Generative Engine Optimization

Strengthen entities: Make your brand/people/products clear everywhere and use structured data.
Publish unique content: Create original data, research, and quotable insights AI can cite.
Write for questions: Use FAQ-style content and natural-language headings that match AI queries.
Maximize citation value: Ensure titles/snippets showcase strong value so users choose to click.

Strategy Shift #3: Optimize for Both “No Click” and “Click”

Zero-Click 2.0 doesn’t mean SEO is dead — it means you have to play on two levels:

When Users Don’t Click

Focus on brand exposure, trust building, and demand creation — ensuring your brand is remembered even without traffic.
Treat this like PR + brand marketing, not traditional SEO.

When Users Do Click

When a user chooses to click through from an AI answer, the page must deliver far more depth and value than the summary they already saw. This means offering richer visuals, comparison charts, calculators, tools, expert commentary, or interactive elements that an AI cannot replicate.
The experience must also be fast, intuitive, and action-oriented — clean mobile UX, strong Core Web Vitals, and clear next steps such as sign-ups, product suggestions, or CTAs. Since fewer users click, every visit should convert more value by being unmistakably better than the AI-generated alternative.

References: